Twinkling Spruce or Aspen: six differences worth knowing
Which tree looks fuller, and how do you make either one fuller?
Edge Best Choice Aspen. Its 3,880 tips are 1,852 more than the Spruce's 2,028, and over the floor each tree covers that is 174 tips per square foot against 103. On our fullness scale that is the top mark, 10, against 8 for the Spruce.
Density takes work. The Aspen's page asks for 1 to 1.5 hours of fluffing. The Spruce's page says three steps and no time. To make either tree look fuller, work from the bottom up, spread each branch tip by tip and push the inner tips out toward the edge. Our fluffing guide shows the order tier by tier, and the extra hour is where the Aspen's advantage gets earned.
| Fullness and light | Twinkling Spruce | Aspen |
|---|
| Tips | 2,028 | 3,880 |
| Tips per square foot of floor | 103 | 174 |
| Lights | 900 | 1,200 |
| Lights per 100 tips | 44 | 31 |
| Floor circle | 19.6 sq ft | 22.3 sq ft |
Edge Best Choice Aspen, on count. Its 1,200 micro LEDs come to 133 per foot against 100 for the Spruce. Spread over the branches, though, the Spruce is the more concentrated of the two: 44 bulbs for every 100 tips against 31, because the Aspen has so many more branches to light. The Spruce also wins on control. Its page names three modes, and a steady-on mode lets you switch the twinkle off. The Aspen's page names no mode, so expect one steady glow until you see the carton.
Which tree has the lab mark, and does either have a warranty?
Edge Best Choice Twinkling Spruce. Its page writes UL-certified LEDs and flame-retardant branches, which earns the full 10 out of 10 for safety words on our scale. The Aspen page writes only flame-retardant tips and scores 5. The page does not say who certified the Spruce's LEDs, so ask the seller for the certificate number.
On warranty it is a tie: neither page writes any. The seller can still honor a claim, so ask before ordering and keep the order record. We found no Best Choice Products recall in the Consumer Product Safety Commission's database on November 14, 2026. Electrical or lighting equipment was involved in two in five home Christmas tree fires from 2020 to 2024, the National Fire Protection Association reports, which is why we weigh the lab mark.
Edge Best Choice Aspen, on paper. Its bullets say PE and PVC, and its technical row says PVC alone, so the share of molded polyethylene tips is not given. The Spruce writes PVC and nothing more. Our needle scores are 8 for the Aspen and 5 for the Spruce, and they rest on those words. Our PE or PVC page explains how to tell the two apart by touch.
Which tree is quicker to put up?
Edge Best Choice Twinkling Spruce. Its page reduces assembly to three steps: unfold the stand, stack the sections from largest to smallest, then fluff. The Aspen has a cordless link between sections, so there is no plug to match at each joint, but the shaping takes 1 to 1.5 hours. At 46.5 lb and 44.5 lb, neither is a one-person carry up stairs.
How much ceiling and floor does each nine-footer need?
Edge Best Choice Twinkling Spruce. The ceiling is a tie: both pages give 108 in with the stand included, so the tree itself reaches a little under 9 ft. With a 9 in topper you need a ceiling of 9 ft 9 in on either one. The floor differs: the Spruce's 60 in base needs a 72 in circle with a 6 in walking margin, and the Aspen's 64 in base needs 76 in, or 6 ft 4 in. Our size calculator checks your own room.
| Room needs | Twinkling Spruce | Aspen |
|---|
| Ceiling with a 9 in topper | 9 ft 9 in | 9 ft 9 in |
| Base | 60 in | 64 in |
| Floor circle with a 6 in margin | 72 in | 76 in |
| Ceiling with no topper | 9 ft | 9 ft |