Where the two small trees part ways
Which small tree stands on less floor and fits a table better?
Edge ClouFairy. Its 30 in base is a circle of 4.9 square feet and the Puleo's 37 in is 7.5. A tabletop has to be at least as deep as the base, and 37 in is wider than many console tables and side tables. A round 36 in dining table would leave the Puleo's lowest branches over the edge.
Height adds up fast too, because the tree stands on whatever you put it on.
| Where it stands | Top with a 9 in topper, ClouFairy | Top with a 9 in topper, Puleo Aspen Fir |
|---|
| The floor | 57 in, 4 ft 9 in | 63 in, 5 ft 3 in |
| A 30 in table | 87 in, 7 ft 3 in | 93 in, 7 ft 9 in |
| A 36 in console | 93 in, 7 ft 9 in | 99 in, 8 ft 3 in |
Neither page says whether the stand is inside the height, so allow a few inches more. Under an 8 ft ceiling, a Puleo on a 36 in console is a tight fit, and a hanging lamp above a table may be lower still. Our size calculator runs the sum for your own surface.
Which tree has more branches?
Edge ClouFairy. On 48 in of height its 566 tips give 142 per foot and 19 per inch of base. The Puleo's 411 tips over 54 in give 91 per foot and 11 per inch. Per square foot of floor, the ClouFairy packs 115 tips and the Puleo 55. On our fullness scale that is a 7 for the ClouFairy and a 4 for the Puleo.
A small tree is easy to make look full, so the number has to be high to stand out, and the ClouFairy's is. The Puleo's branches will show daylight and its lights will read as lights. That is not always a fault: molded tips look best at arm's length, and a small tree is nearly always seen from there. The ClouFairy page says its PE and PVC tips mix to look lush from near and far, a claim we cannot check and a share the page does not give.
Which tree glows brighter?
Edge Puleo. It strings 250 clear lights over 54 in, 56 per foot, against 130 over 48 in, 33 per foot, on the ClouFairy. Per 100 tips the gap is wider: 61 lights on the Puleo, 23 on the ClouFairy. Its page also says the others stay lit if one bulb fails. The ClouFairy page never says what happens when a bulb dies.
Neither page names the bulb type. The ClouFairy writes clear in its table and warm white in a bullet, and the Puleo writes clear and never LED, so neither gets an LED credit from us. On a 4 ft tree with a few reflective ornaments the ClouFairy still reads as lit from across the room.
Which one is easier to carry?
Edge ClouFairy, on what is written. It weighs 6.8 lb, easy for one person. The Puleo page says 1.6 lb, which cannot be the whole tree, since the same maker's 7.5 ft Aspen Fir is 32 lb and this one adds a metal stand with rubber feet. It may be one part or a shipping figure keyed in wrong, so we use no weight in our sums for the Puleo.
Ask the seller for the carton weight if you plan to carry it upstairs or shelve it. The rest of the Puleo page agrees with itself: 54 in matches the 4.5 ft in the title and the 37 in base is written once.
How much safety wording and cover does each page carry?
Edge Puleo. It writes UL-certified lights and two warranties. The ClouFairy writes UL listed lights and flame-retardant branches, and stops there.
| Safety and cover | ClouFairy 4 ft | Puleo Aspen Fir 4.5 ft |
|---|
| Lights | UL listed, in the title and a bullet | UL-certified |
| Branch wording | Flame-retardant PVC | None on the page |
| Written warranty | None | 5 years tree, 2 years lights |
| Use | Not stated; a bullet suggests the garden | Indoor |
| Recall search by title and maker, November 14, 2026 | No entry | No entry |
The ClouFairy has the one oddity that deserves care. A bullet suggests setting the tree in front of the house or in the garden, yet the page names no outdoor or wet-location rating and its recommended-use row is empty. A UL mark means a laboratory certified the lights to a safety standard, and it does not say for which setting. Keep it indoors or under cover until the seller or the cord tag says otherwise. The Consumer Product Safety Commission advises lights from a nationally recognized laboratory, and both pages say so for their lights. Our recall page lists the models and remedies.