Which tree wins, point by point?
Which tree looks fuller from across the room?
Edge Dunhill Fir. It has 1,195 more tips than the Aspen, 1.9 times as many, on a base a single inch wider. Over the floor the tree covers, that is 132 tips per square foot against 72. In plain words, the Dunhill hides the pole and the gaps between tiers, and the Aspen lets some of the structure and the lights show through.
The Dunhill's page also tells you what that density costs: set aside 45 to 60 minutes to peel back the branches and pull the tips apart. The Aspen page gives no shaping time. Budget a quiet evening for either, and read our fluffing guide before you start.
Which tree has the more lifelike needles?
Edge Puleo Aspen Fir, on paper only. Its material line names polyethylene next to PVC, and molded PE tips are the ones that copy the shape of a real needle. Its first bullet calls the tips molded PVC, though, and no page gives the share of PE. The Dunhill names PVC alone. Our needle scores are 10 for the Aspen and 6 for the Dunhill, and they rest on those words, not on a branch in our hands. Our PE or PVC guide shows how to tell the two apart once the tree arrives.
Which tree has the better lights?
Can't call it. Both come to 93 lights per foot on the lower count. The Dunhill's page says 900 dual color LEDs in its description and 700 in its summary line, so you may receive either. What it adds is a choice: white or multicolor, and ten functions that twinkle, flash or fade. The Aspen has fewer ways to play but puts more light on each branch, 53 bulbs for every 100 tips against 28, and its page never says whether the clear bulbs are LED or incandescent.
If you want colored lights, the answer is the Dunhill. If you want one warm, steady glow, the Aspen's clear bulbs are the simpler fit, once the seller confirms the bulb type.
| Lights | Dunhill Fir | Aspen Fir |
|---|
| Bulb count | 700 or 900, both written | 700 |
| Bulb type | LED, dual color | not stated |
| Colors | White or multicolor | Clear |
| Bulbs per 100 tips | 28 | 53 |
| If one bulb fails | not stated | the others stay lit |
Which tree is easier to lift, carry and store?
Edge Puleo Aspen Fir. The 13.2 lb gap is real: 6.0 lb for each foot of the Dunhill against 4.3 for the Aspen. Both fold on hinged branches, so you carry sections and not one block. A 45.2 lb tree is still a two-person job on a staircase, and the 32 lb Aspen can be carried by one adult a section at a time. Floor space is a tie, 19.0 sq ft against 18.4, and with a 6 in walking margin both need a circle about 6 ft across.
Which tree writes more about safety?
Edge Puleo Aspen Fir. Its page names UL-certified lights. The Dunhill names fire-resistant needles but no UL, ETL or CSA mark. The Consumer Product Safety Commission tells buyers to choose lights tested by a nationally recognized laboratory and to look for a "Fire Resistant" label on artificial trees, and each tree meets half of that in writing. We found no recall for either National Tree Company or Puleo in the commission's database on November 14, 2026. The Dunhill runs on a foot pedal, a part type that was recalled in 2020 on other trees, so keep the pedal off the rug and where you can see it. The full list is on our recalls page.